True and False Claims About Coffee and Your Health

Coffee, in all its forms, is absolutely delicious. Here at Foodal, we’re serious about espresso and about the delicious crema that comes with it.

True And False Claims About Coffee And Your Health |

But, lest you think we’re just a bunch of coffee snobs, we actually drink our fair share of lattes, cappuccinos and mochas as well. We never refuse a drip brew or an iced coffee either! (Particularly hard to turn down: a Vietnamese-style iced coffee, made with homemade sweetened condensed milk…)

It’s very likely that you, like us and many millions of Americans, drink at least a couple of cups of coffee-based drinks on any given day. But despite their passion for coffee, most people still consider it a vice, a guilty pleasure or even a necessary evil.

And considering all the myths floating around, it’s entirely natural to wonder if your daily fix isn’t perhaps affecting your body or mind in a negative way.

So if you’re one of the many Americans who are worried about their caffeine intake, and if you’re looking for a bit of scientific guidance in the matter, then do yourself a favor and keep reading.

We scoured a large variety of scientific journals, looking for studies on the effects of caffeine. And by surveying the expert literature, we came to a host of sometimes surprising conclusions about our favorite drink.

What follows is a summary of our findings: first, three common claims about the adverse effects of coffee, and then five proven health benefits.

Claim #1: Coffee Causes Cancer/Heart Disease/Type 2 Diabetes

Two longitudinal studies with over 130,000 test subjects who were followed for a period of 18 to 24 years have made it abundantly clear: even high coffee consumption (up to six cups per day) is not associated with an increased risk of death from any cause, including from cancer or cardiovascular disease.

The common perception of coffee as a pleasant, yet somewhat dangerous habit is thus wrong, at least for the majority of the population that does not suffer from slow caffeine metabolization.

In the case of type 2 diabetes (which accounts for 90-95% of all diabetes cases), the research in fact seems to be pointing in the exact opposite direction: drinking four cups of coffee per day can actually cut your risk of developing this form of diabetes in half, and every additional cup can decrease the risk by another 7%!

Claim #2: Pregnant Women Should Avoid Coffee

There is no absolute certainty (yet) concerning this claim, but scientists do know that caffeine can travel through a pregnant woman’s body, reaching the fetus via the placenta.

What’s more: the fetus has difficulty metabolizing this caffeine. This is thus one claim the scientific evidence tells us not to ignore.

As a result, experts advise women to cut their coffee consumption to an absolute minimum during pregnancy.

Claim #3: Studies Prove That Coffee Is Bad For Your Health

While it is true that older studies often paint a less than pretty picture of coffee, current thinking on the matter has reversed almost completely.

The reason for this reversal is that older research failed to take into account that test subjects who drank a lot of coffee also tended to smoke more tobacco and lead a less active lifestyle than others – an unfortunate correlation which of course skewed the results.

Benefit #1: Coffee Is The Number One Source For Antioxidants

At least in the United States, coffee is by far the most important dietary source for antioxidants, according to scientists from the American Chemical Society.

Though it is true that scientific researchers have recently questioned the perhaps overly enthusiastic treatment of antioxidants in previous decades (and especially the excessive use of supplements), most still link them to protection against various diseases.

Benefit #2: Coffee Makes You Smarter

We all know that coffee provides us with a much-needed energy boost when we haven’t had enough sleep.

However, according to CNN’s Sanjay Gupta’s sources, coffee goes a step further than that and also improves our “reaction time, vigilance, attention and logical reasoning – most of the complex functions [associated] with intelligence.”

Benefit #3: Coffee Is An Enemy Of Parkinson’s Disease

Not only are regular coffee drinkers less likely to develop Parkinson’s disease, but those who are already afflicted by it may be able to combat the onset or worsening of its symptoms by ingesting more caffeine.

Contributors to Neurology, the journal of the American Academy of Neurology, even identified caffeine consumption as a “safe and inexpensive” way to block malfunctioning brain signals associated with Parkinson’s, although they of course do not consider a daily espresso to be adequate treatment by itself.

Benefit #4: Coffee Is Good For Your Liver

Liver cirrhosis (most commonly caused by alcoholism) is a terrible disease, but research proves that it can be prevented to some degree by consuming several cups of coffee per day – each cup potentially decreasing the risk of developing cirrhosis by no less than 22%.

Benefit #5: Coffee Prevents Depression And Even Suicide

Drinking coffee is “weakly related to lower risk of depression” while both sugary and sweetened diet beverages increase this risk, declared a team of neurologists at the 65th annual meeting of the American Academy of Neurology in early 2013.

What’s more, drinking several cups per day may decrease the risk of suicide by about 50%, according to a Harvard School of Public Health study.

So there you have it: a quick overview of some of the most important health benefits of drinking coffee, and a few potential risks as well.

While we hope this knowledge will set your mind at ease by dispelling some persistent myths about the supposed “vice” that is coffee, we do (just like most of the scientists quoted above) caution some degree of moderation.

After all, too much of even a great and wonderful thing as coffee is unlikely to be good for you.

But fortunately for us, and for all lovers of coffee out there in the world, the benefits of moderate or even heavy coffee consumption seem to far outweigh the risks.

So drink up – in moderation!

About Mike Quinn

Mike Quinn spent 20 years in the US Army and traveled extensively all over the world. As part of his military service, Mike sampled coffee and tea from all virtually every geographic region, from the beans from the plantation of an El Salvadorian Army Colonel to "Chi" in Iraq to Turkish Coffee in the Turkish Embassy in Kabul, Afghanistan. He spent nearly a decade in the Republic of Korea where he was exposed to all forms of traditional teas. Mike formerly owned and operated Cup And Brew, an online espresso and coffee equipment retail operation.

5 thoughts on “True and False Claims About Coffee and Your Health”

  1. Interesting read, but I tend to reserve judgement on any health claims I read about food or beverages. Ever sense John Bohannon got a fraudulent study published about chocolate being good for weight loss that the media pounced on like some kind of miracle I am wary of what I see, hear or read on the matter. He did it to make a point of course which I hope was well received. Unless I come by the information from a medical professional or a reputable medical journal as the source I’m hesitant to accept it as being accurate.

  2. I did not know that coffee could be helpful when it comes to depression. I battle with depression on and off and if there’s anything I can take to help me, I’d be more than willing. Will have to start taking a cup a day, ASAP.

  3. I do agree, this is an interesting read and it does dispel several myths. I love coffee and have always been a big drinker until I found it gave me heartburn when I exceeded the limit! Now, I do still drink it, but a lot less. I do know that it is used in the treatment of cancer as we recently experienced with my cousin becoming ill. So, there is a lot of good in it.

  4. Would have been interesting to read something about the effects of coffee on the body when mixed with various fats. The grassfed butter and mct oil mix, is a popular addition to coffee these days and there are many advocating it as an alternative to breakfast.

  5. Coffee has a ton of health benefits actually. I only know because I recently wrote a paper on it. I am working on giving up my daily, morning energy drinks up for coffee. I has more cafeine in the long run, and is much better for me as well.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.