It’s All About Pumpkin Cinnamon Ice Cream This Fall

Fall in Colorado is weird. One minute the leaves are changing and there’s a chill in the air, then the temperature randomly spikes and it feels like a summer day again.

Vertical image of dark orange scoops of dessert in a white bowl, with text on the top and bottom of the image.

Just when you’re settling into the cooler weather, in the blink of an eye, it will suddenly be 90+ degrees outside. It’s oh-so-confusing and it’s one of those things that you just have to learn to love about living here.

You get four seasons each year, but you never know when they are going to change, or how long they are going to stick around.

So, what’s a girl to do when you want all the flavors of fall, but it’s still nice and toasty outside?

All I want to do is have an excuse to be basic AF with mugs of hot cinnamon tea steaming away and pumpkin spice candles burning in every room of my house. Instead, I will complain about the heat and the fact that my daily PSL makes me feel like I am overheating.

Vertical image of a spoon on top of scoops of a dark orange dessert in a white bowl next to pumpkins and cinnamon.

Or, I’ll just dive into a bowl of pumpkin cinnamon ice cream instead.

Yeah, that sounds like a much better idea! Doesn’t it?

This creamy frozen dessert is the best of fall and summer combined, all in one easy-peasy recipe.

Plus, it is a breeze to make, because you don’t even have to cook a custard base from scratch on the stove. Instead, you can just whip up the base right in your blender.

After that it’s smooth sailing, as you throw it in your ice cream maker and watch the results magically appear before your eyes.

Vertical image of a white bowl with scoopfuls of a frozen dessert next to cinnamon sticks.

It also happens to be a lower fat option because it isn’t made with any cream. The funny thing is that it doesn’t change the texture, at least as far as I can tell.

The end result is still nice and creamy… and that’s the best end result, isn’t it? Lower fat, and just as tasty. It’s like a dream come true.

The most torturous part is that you will have to wait for the ice cream to set up in the freezer in an airtight container for a bit after churning. But once you take that first bite, you will feel the cooling bliss of fall run all through your body.

It’s that chill that you need to cool off on those hotter early autumn days, with all of the classic flavors that you start craving the moment that September rolls around each year.

It’s one of those desserts that makes you sink into your seat a little more, with a big sigh of happiness to go along with it.

Vertical top-down image of pumpkins and orange-colored ice cream in white bowls.

I am absolutely in love with this ice cream not only because it’s creamy, but because it has the ideal balance of pumpkin and cinnamon flavors.

It’s like whipping up a pumpkin spice-flavored coffee creamer or a PSL into a frozen dessert.

Be sure to sprinkle it with a little extra cinnamon on top when you serve it, for a double punch of the beloved warming spice. You can also crumble up gingersnap cookies or graham crackers on top if you like, to add a little something crunchy to the mix.

Serve it up in a bowl, a waffle cone, a sugar cone, or even use it to make a milkshake!

Vertical close-up image of a metal spoon holding a spoonful of a spiced pumpkin ice cream dessert, in front of fall decorations.

Pro tip for adults: whip up this ice cream with a little milk and a little vodka for a chilled cocktail that’s perfect for sipping during happy hour on a warm fall day.

This recipe can work really well doubled, as many ice cream makers are have a 2-quart capacity.

Print
Horizontal image of a white bowl with a few scoopfuls of pumpkin ice cream with a metal spoon.

Pumpkin Cinnamon Ice Cream


  • Author: Meghan Yager
  • Prep Time: 30 minutes
  • Total Time: 4 hours, 30 minutes
  • Yield: 1 quart 1x

Description

You know what fall tastes like? Pumpkin cinnamon ice cream. And this homemade dessert is one that you’ll want to shovel into your mouth.


Scale

Ingredients

  • 1 cup Grade B maple syrup
  • 3 cups raw goat’s milk (or whole milk), divided
  • 2 teaspoons freshly grated Ceylon cinnamon + more for garnish
  • 1/2 teaspoons ground nutmeg
  • 7 tablespoons pure pumpkin puree

Instructions

  1. Freeze ice cream maker bowl at least 24 hours in the freezer before making this recipe.
  2. Blend the maple syrup with 1 cup of milk on high speed in a blender, just for a few seconds to incorporate. 
  3. Add cinnamon, nutmeg, and pumpkin and blend until smooth on medium speed. Add the rest of the milk and blend on low speed until combined, about 30 seconds to 1 minute.
  4. Pour mixture into your ice cream maker and process according to manufacturer’s instructions. 
  5. Transfer to an airtight container and place in the freezer. Freeze for at least 4 hours, until fully set.
  6. Serve with freshly grated cinnamon on top.

  • Category: Ice Cream
  • Method: Ice Cream Maker
  • Cuisine: Frozen Dessert

Keywords: pumpkin, cinnamon, pumpkin puree, nutmeg, ice cream

Cooking By the Numbers…

Step 1 – Measure All Ingredients and Freeze Ice Cream Maker Bowl

Horizontal image of squash puree, spices, maple syrup, and milk on a gray surface.

Make sure that you freeze your ice cream maker bowl for at least 24 hours before starting this recipe!

Measure out all of the ingredients as listed on the ingredients list.

I like to use freshly ground cinnamon to make this frozen dessert, and Ceylon is my preferred variety for sweet recipes such as this one. You can read more about using cinnamon in sweet and savory dishes here.

Nutmeg can also be used freshly ground, for a bigger punch of flavor. But in a pinch, pre-ground versions of these spices will also work.

Just try to avoid using anything that has been on your spice rack for too long – though many types of dried spices do have a pretty long shelf life, ground spices will lose their potency more quickly than whole spices. And even whole cinnamon sticks and nutmeg will lose their flavor eventually.

You can also use canned premade or homemade pumpkin puree for this recipe. Just be sure to use the pure, unflavored variety.

Step 2 – Make Base

Horizontal image of a frothy milk mixture in a blender.

Add 1 cup of milk to a blender with the maple syrup. Blend for a few seconds on high speed until combined.

Horizontal image of squash puree on top of frothy milk in a blender.

Add cinnamon, nutmeg, and pumpkin. Blend until smooth on medium speed.

Horizontal image of a light-orange creamy mixture in a blender.

Add the rest of the milk and blend on low speed until combined, about 30 seconds to 1 minute.

Step 3 – Process

Horizontal image of an ice cream maker with a light orange cream mixture.

Transfer the base to your ice cream maker. Process according to manufacturer’s instructions.

Step 4 – Freeze

Horizontal image of a white bowl with a few scoopfuls of pumpkin ice cream with a metal spoon.

Place the semi-frozen mixture in an airtight container. Freeze for at least 4 hours, until fully set.

Serve with a sprinkle of freshly ground cinnamon on top.

Can I Use a Food Processor?

I know that not everyone has a blender. Some people just aren’t into smoothies, and prefer the convenience and variety of options offered by a food processor instead.

Horizontal image of a spoon on top of a bowl of cinnamon-topped ice cream.

Guess what? You can totally make this recipe with your food processor. Simply add everything to the bowl, and process until it’s all mixed up and well-combined.

It’s that season when pumpkin recipes are aplenty. Craving even more? Here are some of our favorites:

Are you a cone or a bowl person when it comes to ice cream? Tell us in the comments below. And when you try the recipe, be sure to rate it here.

Photos by Meghan Yager, © Ask the Experts, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. See our TOS for more details. Originally published by Shanna Mallon on September 29, 2013. Last updated: October 2, 2019 at 11:39 am. With additional writing and editing by Allison Sidhu.

Nutritional information derived from a database of known generic and branded foods and ingredients and was not compiled by a registered dietitian or submitted for lab testing. It should be viewed as an approximation.

Related Posts
Filter by
Post Page
Vegan Halloween Fall Breakfast and Brunch Sides Grains and Legumes Vegetarian Thanksgiving Desserts Pies Smoothies Pancakes Coffee Recipes Gluten Free Snacks Soups & Stews
Sort by

About Meghan Yager

Meghan Yager is a food addict turned food and travel writer with a love for creating uncomplicated, gourmet recipes and devouring anything the world serves up. As the author of the food and travel blog Cake 'n Knife, Meghan focuses on unique foodie experiences from around the world to right at home in your own kitchen.

20 thoughts on “It’s All About Pumpkin Cinnamon Ice Cream This Fall”

  1. Using goats milk is such a great idea! I sometimes have a slight allergy to milk, but I’ve noticed I rarely have issues with goat products so this might just be my dream solution!

    • Of all the milks out there that people can typically get ahold of, goat’s milk is the most similar to human milk. It takes the body about 20 minutes to digest the milk from a goat, where cow’s milk takes about 24 hours to digest. Go goats!

      • Hi Ike,
        Yes, that is one of the things I like about goat milk. It should be noted that cow’s milk can take up to 24 hours to digest. If it is raw and unprocessed it is much easier to digest and it is typically the pasteurized, homogenized milk that takes so long to digest as it is devoid of enzymes and probiotics and full of denatured proteins.

  2. I love using maple syrup to sweeten ice cream too and can imagine it’s just perfect with the pumpkin flavour. The ultimate autumn dessert!

  3. I crave ice cream year round, so no judgement here 🙂 And it’s fun to experiment with seasonal flavors! I love the color and the sound of freshly grated cinnamon on top.

  4. This recipe sounds so awesome, just one question…Can a couple of egg yolks (from pastured hens) be added to this recipe? Thanks!

    • Hi Deborah, of course! I think that would only help make it richer. I simply wanted to try making a good ice cream without yolks or extra cream, but you can definitely add those and they should work really well.

  5. I’ve never seen a goat milk ice cream recipe not use eggs. What’s the consistency like? Is it creamy or more icy? Looks great either way!

    • That’s the thing I love about using maple syrup, the consistency is so much better. Normally the consistency would be more icy when using no cream, eggs, or more fruit, but the syrup really helps it to stay smooth and less icy. It is not as creamy as there is no added cream or eggs, but I did not consider it icy!

  6. Would coconut milk work well with the recipe I don’t have an ice cream maker but do banana ice cream which is basically just blended well frozen banana pieces. Teri

    • Hi Teri,
      I think it would–I have never done it with coconut milk, so I cannot say for sure. You would probably have to blend it and then freeze it and remove it for 15-20 minute periods to stir and mix until blended. Let us know if you try it and if it works!

  7. Thank you so much. I have too much goats milk and dad loves ice cream. This will add to our feasts this year. I am going to try as is: then try with egg yolk. I will only be using fresh pumpkins due to I have many. I need to process them anyway. Pumpkin bread with ice cream, might enhance the desert menu. I will try anything a few times so I don’t have to throw away my milk. I make cheese as well, but most of it is rubber.

  8. Holy bejesus I love it. Creamy, pumpkin goodness. And I made it for about what one pumpkin spice latte costs from the ubiquitous coffee shop we all love so much.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.