Marvelous Mushrooms: How to Choose, Clean, and Store for Long-Lasting Freshness

Mmmmm, mushrooms!

Prep your mushrooms properly for a longer shelf life and delicious flavor- learn how with our tips:
Photo by Lorna Kring.

For instant kitchen gratification, it’s hard to beat a pan full of sizzling mushrooms as they quickly transform from pale fungi to amber-hued morsels of sweet earthiness.

They can be eaten raw of course, and make a fine addition to a tray of veggies with a savory dip like hummus. But raw mushrooms are considered a high FODMAP food, so for those with IBS (irritable bowel syndrome), care should be taken in their consumption to avoid a potential flare-up of symptoms.

But cooking concentrates their woodsy flavor and aroma, making them a natural for a variety of recipes. Baked, sauteed, stuffed, in stews and sauces, atop pizza, or slathered on a steak, their rich taste is distinctive and comforting.

A dry paper towel and pastry brush are all you need to clean fresh mushrooms. Check out more of our fungi-loving tips now on Foodal:
Photo by Lorna Kring.

So, it’s a real disappointment to pull them from the fridge only to discover discolored slime-balls or shriveled up bits of forest debris… they’re not quite so appealing in this situation!

With fragile flesh and a high water content, without proper storage, mushrooms can spoil quickly.

However, with the appropriate storage techniques, mushrooms can last for a week or more in the refrigerator.

To fully enjoy these delicate fungi, let’s have a look at how to select for freshness, the best cleaning techniques, and proper storage for a longer shelf life.

Fresh Selection

For the freshest selection and best quality, choose loose mushrooms whenever possible over prepackaged ones.

This allows you to inspect them closely. Choose only those with fresh, unblemished skin that’s free of discoloration or dry, wrinkly spots. Look for a plump, full appearance with whole, undamaged caps that are still securely attached to the stems.

The texture should be firm and supple, with a cool feel to the hand. Avoid any that are obviously moist, slimy, wrinkled, or spongy.

Clean mushrooms with a dry pastry brush |
Photo by Lorna Kring.

Fragrance is another good pointer to determine freshness and good quality.

The aroma should be slightly sweet, with earthy overtones – like the scent of a walk in the woods in early autumn. Stay away from any that emit a sour or musty odor.

Speaking of walks in the woods, if you plan on foraging for wild fungi, always go with an experienced guide unless you’re very familiar with all the varieties in your region – many poisonous species are similar in appearance to edible ones. And this is a mistake you definitely don’t want to make!

The Mushroom Book: How to Identify, Gather and Cook Wild Mushrooms and Other Fungi

When you do forage, a good guide book with color photos is a valuable resource. The Mushroom Book, available on Amazon, is a solid choice for identification and preparation of wild fungi.

Growing your own is another exciting option. To get started, check out this article on our sister site, Gardener’s Path.

Cleaning Techniques

The easiest way to clean mushrooms, except for morels, is to gently wipe or brush away any dirt and debris.

Fresh morel mushrooms, sliced to show a hollow center |

This can be done with a clean, slightly damp paper towel, or with a soft-bristled brush – like this long-handle brush with natural bristles available on Amazon. Unlike short palm brushes, the long handle makes it easy to reach between the cap and stem.

Burstenhaus Redecker 5-Inch Mushroom Brush with Handle, Natural Pig Bristle

Cut mushrooms should never be washed. The exposed inner flesh will quickly absorb water, leaving them soggy.

And washing whole ones usually isn’t required.

For those of you concerned about the potential of foodborne illness that might be present in the growing substrate (which often contains horse straw or chicken manure), packaged substrates for commercial growers go through pasteurization and sterilization processes to remove any contaminating microorganisms.

This is typically achieved through reaching specific temperatures in the composting process, as well as hot water baths for pasteurization and sterilization with the use of commercial steam sterilizers.

In fact, a Penn State Extension study on the impact of Safety Standards on Mushroom Substrate Composting states that, at the time of writing (updated January 2018), there were no known reports of incidents of foodborne illness from the consumption of fresh, commercially produced mushrooms in North America.

However, if the idea of unwashed mushrooms still bothers you, go ahead and give them a wash – but, do expect a change in texture as they’ll stew rather than fry, and will take longer to cook.

To wash, rinse under a gentle stream of water and dry promptly with a clean, soft dish towel – washing only as many as required for your recipe.

Or, you can use a salad spinner to rinse and spin dry whole ‘shrooms – these are great gadgets for washing many delicate fruits and veggies, not just lettuce.

Foraging for morels |

Morels are the exception to the “no washing” rule. Harvested in the wild, they tend to be a bit dirtier than commercially grown varieties, and their pleated ruffs make a nice habitat for debris and insects to hide in.

For these frilly fungi, a short soak is the best method to loosen and expel grit, dirt, and bugs.

Love morels? We'll teach you how to clean, store and prepare all types of delicious fungi:

Soak morels whole, or halved lengthwise, in cool, lightly salted water for 15 minutes. Drain, and repeat if needed, then rinse in clear running water. Give them a whirl in a salad spinner to air dry, or pat gently with a clean, dry dish towel to absorb water.

They’re Great Dried, Too!

Dried mushrooms can also be used in many recipes, and with a long shelf life of one year in a sealed, airtight container stored in a cool, dark cupboard, they make a convenient addition to the pantry.

When dried, flavors concentrate, and a small amount rehydrated and then added to a dish will contribute a lot of flavor.

They can be used in recipes to replace fresh ones, and make a delicious addition to sauces, soups, stews, a veggie stir fry, or added to pasta, rice, and risotto.

To reconstitute dried fungi, soak in room temperature water. Soaking time depends on the size and thickness, and whether they’re dried or whole.

In general, a 30-minute soak will rehydrate small, thin bits while a couple of hours may be needed for large, thick pieces or whole caps. You’ll know they’re ready for cooking when their flesh is firm, but with a soft, velvety feel.

Clean and store mushrooms properly with these tips:
Photo by Lorna Kring.

After soaking, rehydrated slices should also be rinsed to remove any remaining grit, but don’t throw away the soaking liquid – it has a deep, rich flavor that makes a good addition to sauces, soups, stews, and stock, or to replace a portion of the liquid when cooking rice or risotto.

Drain the soaking liquid through a coffee filter to strain out grit, and store in an airtight container in the fridge for up to a week. It can be frozen as well.

If you find dried fungi to be a little pricey, consider drying them yourself with a home food dehydrator. A dehydrator is a smart way to preserve a bountiful garden harvest or to take advantage of sales, and help to stretch the grocery budget a bit further.

Storage Tips

Because of their delicate flesh and high moisture content, mushrooms can perish quickly. But, there are a couple of keys that will keep them fresh longer:

First, they need to breathe to allow the release of ethylene gas they emit after picking.

How to store mushrooms for proper air flow |
Photo by Lorna Kring.

Second, they need to retain enough moisture to prevent drying out – but not so much as to become slimy.

For loose mushrooms, a perforated ceramic, glass, or stoneware bowl, like a berry bowl, is the ideal option – the perforations allow air circulation, while the bowl material will help to retain moisture. Just wrap them gently in a dry paper towel, place in the bowl, and cover loosely with another dry paper towel.

Creative Co-op Multicolor Stoneware Berry Baskets, Set of 4, available on Amazon

If you don’t have a berry bowl, any bowl will do – or you can always pick up a perforated bowl on Amazon, like these cute ceramic berry baskets.

Always avoid placing fungi in sealed plastic bags, or you’ll have a slimy mess on your hands in no time.

Did you know: contrary to popular myth, storage in paper bags isn’t a great idea either. Most folks fold over the top to seal the bag, but this traps the ethylene, which quickly turns them spongy.

Paper bags are okay, but you need to poke holes in three sides to allow air circulation, and only fold the opening loosely. As ethylene is barely lighter than air, it can become trapped under and around the fungi, and may not fully escape from the open top – poking holes in the bag helps to expel the gas.

Wash and store mushrooms properly with a berry basket for air circulation and drainage |
Photo by Lorna Kring.

If you buy prepackaged mushrooms, leave them in their container. These baskets are usually made of styrene or plastic, and have been designed with air channels to retain freshness.

After opening the seal, leave the remainder in the container and cover loosely with a dry paper towel or loose cling wrap.

Easy Preparation

Aside from cleaning, edible fungi require little in the way of preparation. Using a sharp knife, trim the stem end with a single stroke, and use whole, sliced, chopped, quartered, or halved, as desired.

For stuffed fungi, select large specimens of white (button), cremini, or portobellos – all of which are actually from the same species, Agaricus bisporus, just in different stages of growth.

Remove the base of mushroom stems to prep before cooking |
Photo by Lorna Kring.

When immature, A. bisporus can be either white or brown, and we know them as the familiar button or cremini types, although they have many other names as well. Once mature, they’re referred to as portobellos.

Clean as above and gently twist off the stem, and scoop out the underside gills of large portobellos with a spoon. If the upside-down caps won’t sit flat on your baking surface, slice a fine layer from the cap top to create a level surface.

How to slice fresh mushrooms |
Photo by Lorna Kring.

And don’t discard the stems – they can be finely minced and added to the stuffing, cooked separately and served on the side, added to a sauce, or tossed into a pot of homemade stock or broth.

Delicious Recipes

Need a little more inspiration? Try these fantastic, flavorful recipes from some of our favorite bloggers:

Spicy Mushroom Spinach Frittata

Mushroom and Spinach Frittata in Cast Iron |
Photo © The Domestic Dietitian

Whether you’re looking forward to a lazy brunch or a simple lunch, this frittata recipe is where it’s at, a tasty combo of eggs, veggies, curry powder, and other spices.

The Domestic Dietitian shares the recipe.

Cheesy Mushroom and Tomato Dip

The Best Mushrooms Julienne with Tomato Slices and Cheese |
Photo by Nikki Cervone.

This veggie julienne is like a creamy tomato and mushroom-packed queso fundido, a mix of melted cheese and veggies that’s perfect for dipping or spreading on toast. Serve it as an afternoon snack, an appetizer before a holiday meal, or even an accompaniment to brunch. This is comfort food at its finest!

Get the recipe now on Foodal.

Asian-Inspired Mushroom Dumplings

Homemade mushroom dumplings are just one of the recipes we share from our favorite fungi-loving bloggers:
Photo © Sugar Love Spices

From the shitake filling to the flavorful dipping sauce, these dumplings are a must-make. Each part of the dish is made from scratch, including the wonton wrappers, and the extra effort required is so worth it.

Find the recipe now on Sugar Love Spices.

Mushroom, Pea, and Gruyere Picnic Pies

What's the usual shelf life of a mushroom? Try our kitchen hacks:
Photo © Feast in Thyme

Travel-ready picnic food? Yes, please! Simple to make in a muffin tin, you’re going to love this veggie-packed take on savory pastry. Oh, and these mini pies make a delicious party appetizer as well.

Check out the recipe on Feast in Thyme.

Cream of Mushroom Soup

Do you know how to clean portobellos before cooking? Or how to store shiitakes? What about the proper way to reconstitute dehydrated morels? We'll teach you all this and more- try our tips:
Photo © Vintage Kitty

If you’re a mushroom soup lover, nothing beats the kind that is lovingly made from scratch at home. Delicious on its own, alongside a sandwich, or even stirred into a green bean casserole, this dish is soon to become a household staple.

Get the recipe now, from Vintage Kitty.

Portobello Pizzas

Are you a fungi fan? Delicious in a variety of dishes and cuisines, we'll teach you how to select, clean, and store these beauties:
Photo © The Fitchen

If you’re looking for a low-carb solution, skip the crust and make these mini pizzas with portobellos instead. Stuffed with sauce, melted cheese, and your favorite veggie toppings, these can be thrown together quickly – perfect for Meatless Monday and other weeknights when you’re looking for an easy dinner solution.

Get the recipe now on The Fitchen.

Southwest Vegan Steak and Potatoes

Mushrooms are so versatile- but do you know how to store them, or how to use them in your cooking? We share our tips:
Photo © Kitchen Window Clovers

Think steak is off the table, once you’ve adopted a vegan diet? Think again!

Okay, okay – we know this isn’t a true steak dinner. But the delicious flavor and texture of mushrooms utilized here provides a nice alternative for those who eschew meat, and it’s another dinner option that can be made quickly on busy nights.

You’ll find the recipe over on Kitchen Window Clovers.

Wild Mushroom Tuscan Risotto

Try our tips to choose, clean, and store fresh mushrooms- plus recipes from some of our favorite bloggers:
Photo © Wanderspice

Mushroom is a beloved flavoring for risotto, and this recipe features your favorite variety – the choice is completely up to you! So head on down to the farmers market or your favorite local purveyor, pick up whatever types look good, and start cooking.

Head on over to Wanderspice to get the recipe.


Although mushrooms are considered to be a vegetable when it comes to culinary use, in scientific classification they actually belong to the fungi kingdom.

And although mostly pale-fleshed, all varieties have surprisingly high levels of certain antioxidants. These are most notably ergothioneine and glutathione, which may play an important role in the reduction of neurodegenerative diseases associated with aging.

They’re also low in calories, fats, and sodium, and provide small but important levels of vitamin D, fiber, niacin, potassium, proteins, riboflavin, and selenium.

Make Meals Marvelous

As the old Money’s brand ad said, mushrooms make meals marvelous!

And with the right storage methods, you’ll be able to enjoy their fresh quality for at least a week, or more.

Buy loose ones for the best selection, clean gently with a paper towel or brush, and allow them to breathe to extend their shelf life – then revel in the sweet, nutty goodness of these fine fungi!

How to prepare and store mushrooms for cooking |
Photo by Lorna Kring.

Do you readers have any favorite mushroom ideas to share? Let us know in the comments below.

Don’t forget to Pin It!

Mushrooms are a beloved ingredient for many dishes, adding a rich, umami flavor to vegetables, egg dishes, meats, and more. Easy to prepare, they unfortunately don’t have an extensive shelf life once picked – but with the proper storage techniques, you can enjoy their fresh flavor for much longer. Join us now for a look at how to choose, clean, and store these tasty fungi!

Photos by Lorna Kring and Nikki Cervone, © Ask the Experts, LLC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.See our TOS for more details. Photo credit Recipe photos used with permission. Product photos via Knopf, Redecker, Creative Co-op. Uncredited morel photos: Shutterstock. With additional writing and editing by Allison Sidhu.

The staff at Foodal are not medical professionals and this article should not be construed as medical advice. Foodal and Ask the Experts, LLC assume no liability for the use or misuse of the material presented above. Always consult with a medical professional before changing your diet, or using supplements or manufactured or natural medications.

About Lorna Kring

Recently retired as a costume specialist in the TV and film industry, Lorna now enjoys blogging on contemporary lifestyle themes. A bit daft about the garden, she’s particularly obsessed with organic tomatoes and herbs, and delights in breaking bread with family and friends.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.