Vanilla Spice Cookies: The Smell and Taste of a Christmas Market

As you know, I’m not exactly the type of person to miss winter. But can I tell you something?

A stack of vanilla spice cookies | Foodal

When these vanilla spice cookies bake, even in the middle of May, filling the kitchen with a fragrance sweet and filled with nostalgia, I’d swear I was walking around a Christmas market where they sell fresh-roasted cinnamon pecans wrapped in paper cones.

The kind you take in your gloved hands, the air visible in front of you as you breathe in and out, your face flushed pink.

It’s like that time last winter when my friend Becky and I drove out to Geneva, on, I swear, what must have been the coldest night ever, on the hunt for homemade candy canes and cups of hot chocolate.

After we walked up and down a street of bundled carolers and holiday decorations, our skin cracking and our noses running, what we found instead were frozen toes and fingers, even after returning to the car; a few photos of us, in the dark, standing near twinkling lights; and my first taste of a chestnut, which, in all honestly, smells a hundred times better than it tastes: hot and bland.

I don’t often feel nostalgic for nights like those, so it would take something pretty special to make me remember all the good parts: the smell of fresh popcorn from the white tent in front of one of the shops, the gleaming red and gold globes hanging from a tree, the group of musicians who played, hands exposed, as if they couldn’t even feel the freeze.

Let me tell you: these cookies are that something.

Vanilla Spice Cookies on a Silpat Baking Sheet

They came to me the other night, quickly, because I had the ingredients on hand and because, as icebox cookies, I figured they’d hold up well to shipping. I was planning a package for my friend Jarrelle.

You’d like Jarrelle. We met in college, I can’t remember when exactly, but she’s the kind of person that is easy to like, in a way that not many people are, and if she lived a little closer to Chicago instead of New Hampshire, I’d be going over tonight to visit and give her a big hug, which is exactly what she needs right now.

The original recipe for these cookies calls for chopped nuts, which I omitted, and the weirdest thing was that an almost nutty flavor still came through.

It’s like these cookies were all the best parts of candied pecans – the sweetness, the slight caramelizing – without the actual nuts underneath. Fresh out of the oven, they are nothing short of irresistible.

The original recipe suggests dipping the cookies in chocolate icing, so by all means try that. I, however, like them just as they are. Also, the recipe as it is yields around 80; feel free to freeze the logs to bake later, whenever the mood strikes (dough may be frozen several months).

The Recipe

A stack of vanilla spice cookies | Foodal
Vanilla Spice Cookies
Votes: 1
Rating: 5
Rate this recipe!
Print Recipe
A stack of vanilla spice cookies | Foodal
Vanilla Spice Cookies
Votes: 1
Rating: 5
Rate this recipe!
Print Recipe
  • 1/2 cup unsalted butter softened
  • 1 cup firmly packed brown sugar
  • 1 egg*
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 3/4 cups all purpose flour
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt
  • 1/2 cup chopped pecans (optional)
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground cardamom
  1. In the bowl of a stand mixer, beat butter on medium speed and gradually add the sugar, beating well. Add egg and vanilla, and beat well.
  2. In a separate bowl, combine the flour, baking soda, salt, chopped pecans, and spices. Add this dry mixture to the butter mixture and stir to combine.
  3. Shape the dough into two approximately 12-inch logs. Wrap each in wax paper and chill for at least two hours.
  4. When ready to bake, preheat oven to 350°F. Unwrap dough and cut into 1/4-inch slices. Place on ungreased (or Silpat-lined) baking sheets, and bake for 10 to 12 minutes.
  5. Cool slightly on baking sheets, then remove to wire racks to cool completely.
Recipe Notes

Adapted from Genius Kitchen.


Related Posts
Filter by
Post Page
Desserts Baking Cakes Christmas Cookies German Herbs and Spices Cupcakes Breakfast and Brunch Sauces and Spreads Vegan Smoothies Gluten Free Vegetarian Spring
Sort by

About Shanna Mallon

Shanna holds an MA in writing from DePaul University. Her mantra? Restoring order and celebrating beauty through creative content, photography, and food. Shanna's work has been featured in Bon Appetit, The Kitchn,, Everyday Health, Better Homes & Gardens,, Food News Journal, Food52, Zeit Magazine, Chew the World,, Babble,, Parade, Foodista, Entrepreneur and Ragan PR.

24 thoughts on “Vanilla Spice Cookies: The Smell and Taste of a Christmas Market

  1. Both cookies look fantastic! Thanks for sharing them! I know about those recipes that just inspire some much nostalgia and reminisance (I’m not sure how to spell that word, let’s flow with it!) they taste better, they take on a special meaning and a dear place in your heart. I could have some cinnamon-roasted nuts right about now! And a cookie! One of each actually. And a glass of milk!

  2. they look delicious! i’m sure they’ll brighten your friend’s day… i had to mail some “heartbreak” cookies to a far-away friend a little while ago. i think they’re the best substitute for an in-person hug!

  3. The Death by Chocolate look amaaaazing. Got any left? Because if you bring some of those in on Tuesday, I’ll bring some of my homemade Oatmeal cookies!!

  4. Those vanilla spice cookies are right up my alley. I love that you provided a vanilla alternative to the chocolate, and that you gave the vanilla cookie top billing! Thanks for the recipe.

  5. Chocolate Angie – Absolutely!

    Marta – Your comment made me smile. You’d be lovely to share a cookie and milk with.

    DD – I agree! Cardamom is underused!

    Thanks, Rae!

    Carolyn – A friend sent me some cookies in December, and I almost cried, I was so happy!

    Whitney – Exactly!

    Sue, LOL! I wish we could have a baking day together (with Elyse, of course!)

    Alicia – None left, but I’m holding you to the oatmeal promise. Can’t wait!

    Purple Foodie – I know!

    Jess – You are sweet. Thank you!

  6. I have been on the lookout for a simple yet delicious cookie. On my list of things to bake tomorrow are your Vanilla Spice cookies.

    Your blog is fantastic! I love the layout and your writing.

  7. I made the chocolate cookies last night and they turned out really flat. Tasty, but super flat. I made the first pan with room temperature dough, and the second with chilled dough. Both versions turned the same way. Any suggestions?

  8. I just received the new Bath and Body- Winter Spice and Vanilla hand soap and thought wow- wouldn’t it be great to eat something that smelled just like this. So, I’ve been trying to decode the smell and find a recipe that would taste this good. Just made the Vanilla Ccookies and have them in the fridge doing their icebox thing. I have high hopes for this recipe as the use of cardomom/ with lots of vanilla would be just right.

    • Sadie (I love your name!), I haven’t made these in quite a while, but the main thing I remember is the smell. Just like Christmas! Would love to hear what you think once they’re done!

  9. I made a big log but cut it in half lengthwise/sliced and baked for 12 mins. Texture was a wee bit chewy yet crisp-and the smell and taste was spicy but mellow and fresh and not overpowering. I put course sugar on top before baking and that looked nice. I didn’t use convection but next time I will. It wasn’t exactly the smell/taste I was looking for but close. I will try again with the same recipe and spices and add vanilla bean seeds or get a better quality vanilla. I’m very intrigued by that soap smell and plan to contact B.B.W. and ask about the scent mixture.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.