How to Roast Peppers

Step 1: Get your hands on a fresh red pepper

I bought a $1 red pepper at the Oak Park Farmers Market recently, picking it up only because it was this beautiful shade of red and, frankly, seemed to be calling my name, all shiny and fragrant. Before I knew what I was doing, I was walking away from the tent with it, thinking I could figure the rest (as in, what to do with it) out later. (This, apparently, is my thing, the way yours might be that you’re always on time or never forget a birthday. I am the girl who can’t plan ahead, who buys and then thinks, who starts recipes late at night before reading the entire directions.)

Step 2: Roast the pepper

A few days after buying the one red pepper, I’d used a fourth of it, along with a fourth of a green pepper, in an impromptu scrabbled eggs(ish) medley, which I ate but you probably wouldn’t—trust me—and every time I opened the fridge, the remaining 3/4 of the peppers taunted me. So something had to be done.

2a: Put the pepper on a cookie sheet and place in the oven at 375 degrees.

Wash the peppers before placing them on the sheet, and leave on their stems—they’ll help with handling later. You will notice, from the photo, that I did this with both the green and red peppers. Let’s just say one was more cooperative than the other.

2b: Cook peppers for about an hour, rotating them every 20 minutes or so.

This is my favorite part, because the peppers fill your kitchen with a wonderful, peppery smell that makes your stomach growl. Plus, they wrinkle up like crazy and look like your toes do after being in the bathtub too long. And, I don’t know, I think that’s kind of fun.

2c: Remove the sheet from the oven and enclose the peppers.

There are many ways to do this: place the hot peppers in a bowl that you cover with plastic wrap, stick them in a paper bag that you close up tight or, what I did, use the fresh tin foil that you always line your baking sheets with (less cleaning!) to create a sort of domed enclosure around the peppers. Leave them like this for a little while; the steam will help loosen their skins.

A batch of roasted red bell peppers | Foodal

2d: Peel off the skins of the peppers and separate them into thin strips.

After they’ve steamed for a bit, the peppers will be easy to peel (at least my red pepper was). The thin skin comes right off, sometimes in pieces and, best, sometimes in one huge section. Put the soft fleshy strips (removed from all seeds and skin) into a small casserole dish.

Step 3: Eat roasted pepper!

I thought you might like a snack at this juncture in the process (OK, what I mean to say is I did), so here is what you should do: douse the pepper slices in a little olive oil and sea salt and sop them up with toasted bread. YUM. Afterwards, I had about three tablespoons left for the dip recipe.

Step 4: Make the dip

In a medium-sized skillet, heat about a teaspoon of olive oil. Meanwhile, dry and chop up what you have left of red peppers—it should be around three tablespoons, but it’s flexible. Also, chop up a clove of garlic. Add the peppers and garlic to the skillet and heat for around a minute.

Add a tablespoon of balsamic vinegar, and put the skillet on low-medium heat. Leave it be for a little more than 10 minutes.

When the mixture is fairly dry and very soft, pour it from the skillet into a bowl to cool. Add 1/2 cup sour cream, a teaspoon of dried basil (and maybe a bit of sea salt for good measure) and stick it in the refrigerator.

After it’s chilled, serve with pita bread.

Related Posts
Filter by
Post Page
Veggies Vegan Sandwiches Vegetarian Sides Salads Appetizers Sauces and Spreads Middle East / Mediterranean Dips Hummus Grains and Legumes Easter Spring Blender Recipes Guides Beef Slow Foods Protein
Sort by

About Shanna Mallon

Shanna holds an MA in writing from DePaul University. Her mantra? Restoring order and celebrating beauty through creative content, photography, and food. Shanna's work has been featured in Bon Appetit, The Kitchn, MSN.com, Everyday Health, Better Homes & Gardens, Houzz.com, Food News Journal, Food52, Zeit Magazine, Chew the World, Mom.me, Babble, Delish.com, Parade, Foodista, Entrepreneur and Ragan PR.

9 thoughts on “How to Roast Peppers

  1. Wow, you got quite a bit out of those two peppers…what is really good is a piece of french baguette, topped with goat cheese or creme cheese, topped with roasted pepper. Yum.

  2. Raina: I will have to try that–honestly, I love a bit of French baguette topped with almost anything!

    RobinSue: Honestly, when I wrote this post, my stomach started growling, lol! 🙂

  3. i love the flavor of red pepper and yellow. I actually dont prefer green. I think it is because it is much more savory–less sweet.
    I do LOVE LOVE LOVE the red flavor. i want to try the dip!!!

  4. i love the taste of red peppers, and jab loves the green ones for their slight bitterness. you have such patience to roast. i would’ve just stuffed them with some rice, ground meat and called it a day!

  5. Rachel: I’ve heard a few other people say the same thing about green (but have you had it on pizza? YUM).

    Lan: See, now, you had to say that, right? Guess what I’m hungry for now?

  6. Thanks for the tips on roasting red peppers. I clicked on your link because I’m making roasted red pepper pasta tonight http://thepioneerwoman.com/cooking/2009/03/pasta-with-roasted-red-pepper-sauce-groan/ (which is delicious, by the way) and I was glad to see that you explained how to roast them in the oven; the recipe I’m using suggests using a grill, which I don’t have. (I have used the toaster oven, which works.)

    But now after reading about your dip, I really wish I had an extra pepper to make that also! Maybe I’ll go get some more soon!

  7. Happy to help! Roasted red peppers are amazing and I really need to make them again. Thanks for the link to the pasta recipe, too! (PS – you have an Etsy! Congrats!)

  8. Thanks! I ended up cooking them a lot longer than planned; probably, next time I’ll make the oven hotter to expedite the process.

    They sure do get expensive; next year, I’m going to plant some in the garden!!

    That pasta recipe turned out fantastic. I think you would like it. Roasting and peeling/seeding the red pepper was the only somewhat labor-intensive part, and that’s not bad.

    Thanks for noticing my Etsy — I only put a couple of things on there so far; it needs a lot of work. But maybe it will turn out to be some fun!

Leave a Comment

0 Shares